That Time Jews Smuggled Chocolate to France — and a Recipe for Basque Chocolate Cake
Published July 13, 2016 at The Forward
I happened into a chocolate shop, L’Atelier du Chocolat de Bayonne in Paris in 2006 with my husband. As we were tasting and browsing, I randomly picked up a company brochure. In my high school French, I slowly deciphered this astonishing statement:
À Bayonne l’origine de la fabrication et de la consommation du chocolat semble remonter au début du VXIIème siècle, lorsque les Juifs pourchassés par l’Inquisition s’installèrent dans le bourg de Saint Esprit.
At Bayonne the origins of the manufacturing and the consumption of chocolate happened at the beginning of the seventeenth century, when the Jews exiled from the Inquisition settled in the suburb of Saint Esprit.
First, I had to remind myself that this meant Bayonne, in southwest France, and not Bayonne, New Jersey. Then, I re-read the passage because in all of my years of Jewish studies, seminary and teaching about Jews and Judaism, I had never known of any connection between Jews and chocolate. And, it was, after all just my high school French. I would not have been surprised that Jews like chocolate. However, this was telling me that Sephardi Jews, exiled from Spain, brought chocolate making to France. Oooh, la, la.
It turns out that Bayonne Jews such as Emil Péreire, Isaac Péreire, Alvaro Luiz, Jacome Luiz, and Aaron Colace were in the business of importing, exporting, and smuggling cacao. Jews played a key role in this profitable trade through Bayonne to Amsterdam.
When I looked further, I learned that Jews molded that chocolate and its reputation. In September, 1725, it was reported that Bayonne chocolate for drinking was sold in marble-sized balls prepared on a stone (à la Pierre), or as known in the New World, a metate. With time, the reputation of Bayonne chocolate was so well established that dealers in Carcassonne, a fortified town also in the southwest of France, preferred chocolate from the Bayonne area known as à la Bayonnaise.
Many sources repeat this idea that Jews imported chocolate making to France including The Encyclopaedia Judaica, Mort Rosenblum’s book Chocolate: A Bittersweet Saga and Joan Nathan’s book about French Jewish cooking. In Bayonne itself we observed that many chocolate stores, several museums, and the city’s tourist literature reiterate the Jewish origins of French chocolate. Without question, this account of Jews introducing chocolate making to France became quite popular in Bayonne.
This pride in the Jewish origins of French chocolate overshadows the complications bubbling in the town’s chocolate past. The Jewish chocolate makers of seventeenth-century Bayonne encountered discrimination, jealousy, and anti-Semitism. Jews could not own or rent commercial or residential property outside of the St. Esprit suburb. They could not live in Bayonne proper. Jews had to leave the city of Bayonne each evening by sunset and were prohibited from selling chocolate on Sundays or Christian feast days.
In citing Bayonne as the original site of French chocolate preparation due to Jews, today’s French chocolate industry has sought to reestablish Bayonne’s authenticity and primacy in a revived post-World War II French chocolate industry. Claiming Bayonne as the center of continuous chocolate manufacture in France overlooks the discrimination against Jews by Bayonnais merchants and nobles. We may speculate about when the first creation of chocolate in France occurred or whether that chocolate was made by a Jew. In this complicated reassertion of its chocolate heritage, Bayonne privileges the idea that Sephardi Jews introduced chocolate fabrication to France.
So, in honor of Bastille Day eat a bit of chocolate, or some French chocolate, or make this popular Bayonne Basque Chocolate Cake. Either way, rejoice that Jews have been in chocolate, l’dor va’ dor, from generation to generation.
Basque Chocolate Cake
¾ cup unsalted butter
5½ ounces bittersweet chocolate
3 large eggs
¾ cup sugar
1⁄3 cup all-purpose flour
¾ cup black cherry preserves, for serving
Crème fraîche, for serving
1) Preheat the oven to 375°F.
2) Lightly butter and flour a 9-inch round cake pan. In a large heatproof bowl set over a pan of simmering water, combine the butter and chocolate. Melt over moderate heat, stirring frequently, until smooth, about 4 minutes. Remove from the heat and let cool slightly. In a medium bowl, using an electric mixer, beat the eggs with the sugar at high speed until thick and pale, about 3 minutes. Add the flour and beat at low speed just until combined. Fold in one-third of the melted chocolate, then gently fold in the remaining chocolate; do not over mix.
3) Pour the batter into the prepared pan and bake for 20–30 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted into the center comes out clean. Invert the cake onto a rack and let cool.
4) In a saucepan, warm the cherry preserves over moderate heat. Cut the cake into wedges and serve with the cherry preserves and crème fraîche.
Book Optioned: Museum Exhibit
Excerpted from my remarks at Opening Night at Temple Emanu-El, NYC, October 20, 2017: Some people have books optioned for movies. I am so delighted that my book, On the Chocolate Trail (2nd Edition, 2017) has become a museum exhibit… Thank you, Warren Klein, for your professionalism, creativity and collegiality in creating Semite Sweet, which displays someRead more ›
Announcing Second Edition: On the Chocolate Trail
Media attention, popular culture, audience questions, growing consumer awareness, and changes in the chocolate world sparked the new material in this second edition of On the Chocolate Trail. I am happy to offer up a totally new chapter, “Gods in My Chocolate,” which explores twenty-first-century controversies about deities formed from chocolate. While chocolate generallyRead more ›
No End to Chocolate Exhibits Part III: Visits #3, 4 & 5
A stunning number of exhibits about chocolate, mostly on the East Coast, captured our attention in the last six months. Mark and I had the opportunity to visit three very different exhibits, what I call #3, 4 & 5. I reviewed the exhibit (#1) at Detroit Institute of Arts (DIA), where I was honored toRead more ›
Of Chocolate Exhibits There is No End: Part 2
Just as the Detroit Institute of Arts closes its wonderful Bitter|Sweet display of chocolate, coffee and tea, no need to despair. New York offers three additional exhibits. Setting aside the wondrous and elegant chocolate shops, at least three local museums currently exhibit artifacts related to the history and consumption of chocolate. For now, the newRead more ›
Some Previous Posts
(in alphabetical order)
- Adventures On the Chocolate Trail: Atlanta, Portland, Seattle
- Anschluss Launches Bartons Passover Favorites 77 Years Ago
- Bat Mitzvah Wants Fair Trade Israeli Chocolate
- Bringing Buckeye Candy to Experts
- Chocolate Expo
- Chocolate Made My Lunch: Nashville
- Chocolate, Coffee, Tea and Me
- Election 2016: Winning Fudge Brigadeiros
- Fathering Chocolate
- Hunting for Chocolate: Fancy Food Show, NYC, 2016
- Labor Day in our Chocolate
- Local Chocolate in the South
- Minding Our Chocolate
- No End to Chocolate Exhibits Part III: Visits #3, 4 & 5
- Of Chocolate Exhibits There is No End: Part 2
- On the Chocolate Trail in Brooklyn
- Seriously Tasting Chocolate
- Super Food Chocolate for Super Bowl Sunday: Three Recipes
- Ten Teaspoons of Sugar in My Chocolate?
- That Time Jews Smuggled Chocolate to France — and a Recipe for Basque Chocolate Cake